The Journal of Critical Analysis of Judicial Decisions

Volume & Issue: Volume 5, Issue 9, August 2026, Pages 1-684

Number of Articles: 22

Editor-in-Chief Lecture: Judicial Socialism

Pages 9-17

10.22034/analysis.2026.738984

Mohammad Javad Shariatbagheri

Making Civil Liability fair in the Iranian Legal system by Using a Kind of Relative Standard (Critique and Justification of Judicial Precedent Based on a Philosophical, Paradigmatic and Comparative Study)

Pages 18-34

10.22034/analysis.2026.738985

Mohammad Darvishzadeh

Making Civil Liability fair in the Iranian Legal system by Using a Kind of Relative Standard (Critique and Justification of Judicial Precedent Based on a Philosophical, Paradigmatic and Comparative Study)

Pages 35-68

10.22034/analysis.2026.2079317.1157

Alireza Abin

Delay in Payment of what is Fairly Given in Exchange for Private Lands and Real Estate and the Necessity of Compensation for Late Payment: Reexamining the Government's Eighteen-month Deadline (with Emphasis on the Critique of Judgments Rendered by the Courts of Province of Lorestan)

Pages 69-93

10.22034/analysis.2026.2080791.1169

Rahim Pilvar, Hosein Borji

A Critical Review of Binding Precedent Rendered by Supreme Court on Claims for Compensation for Delayed Payment after the Cessation of Payments by a Bankrupt Merchant in Light of the Substantive Evolution of this Legal Institution

Pages 94-124

10.22034/analysis.2026.2094678.1213

Mohammad Mahdi Tavakoli, Mohammad Hashemi

The Mechanism of Subrogation of the Insurer on Behalf of the Insured in Claim Based on Recovering Compensation Against the Driver Who Caused the Accident: Critique of Judgment Rendered by the Broojen Civil Court

Pages 125-159

10.22034/analysis.2026.2080788.1170

Hosein Javar

Moral and Material Compensation Arising out of Eleven Years of Wrongful Imprisonment: An Analytical–Comparative Examination of Judgments Rendered by Branch 20 of the Tehran Public Civil Court and Branch 25 of the Tehran Provincial Appellate Court

Pages 160-211

10.22034/analysis.2026.2083196.1183

Mohammad Hadi Javaherkalam

Critique of the Decision Made by Fars Appellate Court Concerning the Civil Liability of a Physician

Pages 212-240

10.22034/analysis.2026.2080180.1163

Fatemeh Sadat Hosseini

False Imprisonment Liability: Commentaries on a Judicial Decision

Pages 241-280

10.22034/analysis.2026.2080195.1164

Abdollah Rajabi

Plane Crash and Compensation in the Balance of Ethics and Law;A Critique of Judgment Rendered by Chamber 180 of Tehran’s Public Civil Court at Shahid Mottahari Judicial Complex

Pages 281-311

10.22034/analysis.2026.2082961.1181

Milad Sadeghi

Civil liability of a Physician in Case of A Disease: An Examination of A Judgment Related to Wrongful Birth

Pages 312-340

10.22034/analysis.2026.2083710.1185

Afrouz Samadi

A Critique and Justification of Judicial Precedent When Compensating for Devaluation of Money in Tortious Liability

Pages 341-373

10.22034/analysis.2026.2080199.1171

Taha Arabasadi, Amir Ghaffari

From Liability to Immunity: An Analysis and Critique of Judgment Rendered by Tehran Criminal Court II and the Approach Taken by the Appellate Court to State Liability Regarding COVID-19 Vaccination, with Reference to the Experience of Other Legal Systems

Pages 374-431

10.22034/analysis.2026.2086114.1194

jalil ghanavati, mahshid jafari harandi

The Nature of the Damage Caused by Deprivation of Economic Benefits in Terms of Loss of Profit or Possibility of Obtaining it and the Conditions for Establishing a Causal Relationship in Economic Damages that Occur in a Chain Reaction; Analysis of the Judgment Rendered by Ardebil Court of First Instance and Provincial Appellate Court

Pages 432-461

10.22034/analysis.2026.2079769.1160

smaeil keshavarz safi yi

Critique of the Decision Rendered by a Branch of the Supreme Court on the "Clearly Unlawful" Nature of the Excessive Penalty Clause

Pages 462-483

10.22034/analysis.2026.2079931.1161

Hassan Mohseni

Compensation for Moral Damages Resulting from an Illicit Relationship; A study of Judgment Rendered by Shiraz Public Civil Court

Pages 484-512

10.22034/analysis.2026.2082251.1178

khadijeh Mozafari, Maryam Najafi

The Binding Precedent No. 788 Rendered by Supreme Court; the Exemption of Guarantors of Bankrupt Merchants from Liability for Delay Damages

Pages 513-534

10.22034/analysis.2025.2074145.1127

Ahmadreza mousavi, Maryam Mohajeri

The Confusion Concerning Initial Point of Calculation of Late Payment Damages in Cheques: A Study of Judicial Precedent Following Binding Precedent No. 812, Rendered by the Supreme Court

Pages 535-579

10.22034/analysis.2026.2078976.1151

Meghdad Momenianmasouleh, abbas niazi

Market Trouble :An Analysis of a Judgment Concerning Unauthorized Adaptation of a Biography in a Cinematic Production: Profit or the Opportunity to Make a Profit?

Pages 580-607

10.22034/analysis.2026.2084069.1190

ABBAS Mirshekari, Mona Abdi

Analysis of the Nature of Loss of Profit in the Iranian Judicial Precedent through a Comparative Study in French Law

Pages 608-637

10.22034/analysis.2026.2080025.1162

Samira Harati Ghavi

The Binding Precedent No. 811 Rendered by the Supreme Court from the Perspective of the Theory of Lucrative Fault with a Comparative study in French law

Pages 638-671

10.22034/analysis.2026.2078802.1152

Mostafa Harati

Selected Judgement

Pages 672-684

10.22034/analysis.2026.738982

The Journal of Critical Analysis of Judicial Decisions

Journal Archive

Volume 5 (2026)

Issue 9

Volume 4 (2025)

Volume 3 (2024)

Volume 2 (2023)

Volume 1 (2022)